Freddie deBoer:
"I am angry, because Avent didn't just dismiss my essay without argument. He instead decided to attack my field. [...] This is what Twitter is for, and this is indicative of the entire operation of prominent bloggers: socially and professionally connected people who defend each other no matter what, excluding and marginalizing dissent, ignoring unpalatable arguments that they can't answer, and in every way undermining as illegitimate criticisms that don't operate from a position of privilege and social authority."To blame this all on Twitter is a little much. It's less "what Twitter is for" and more "what prominent bloggers and media personalities use Twitter for."
What I'm using Twitter for:
- Sharing links, punning, and brief inspirational quotes can all be done comfortably within the space of a tweet. I could put these things on the blog, but I think it saves time for everyone if I just drop them in the
- Short, troll-free conversations with bloggers. Easy questions and further links are easy to get, and unwanted, uninteresting, or unhelpful responses are easy to cut out of the conversation, and even blocked if need be. This is as opposed to comment sections on blog posts, which get flooded to the point of uselessness on websites of any size. It's also nice to have all these conversations in one place, rather than distributed across a bunch of websites you have to hold open in tabs.
- As for the troll filter: yeah, this cuts both ways, and can be used to exclude unpopular perspectives, especially if you've got a ton of followers. But, oh my goodness, the spatial metaphor is so much nicer. I've really grown to hate the entitlement complexes of trollish commenters on unmoderated blogs. Would you come into my house and say these things?
3 comments:
Two things:
1) I have no idea what Twitter is for.
2) Freddie is entirely too sensitive, not just in this case but in general.
Then again, I can be a total f-ing a-hole. So, I have a slightly distorted view of how insensitive people should be to other people's opinions whether they be unfair, stupid or otherwise.
1) It takes a while.
2) I don't care about the spat with Avent. I do have a small problem with empty snark, but clearly I'm in a much lower having-a-problem bracket than Freddie is.
I just read that paragraph and realized it didn't have a thing to do with how I use the site.
I think you nailed it.
Post a Comment